Sweet Sarah's


Visit Our Store

Monday 9am-7pm
Tuesday 9am-7pm
Wednesday 9am-7pm
Thursday 9am-7pm
Friday 9am-7pm
Saturday 9am-7pm
Sunday Closed

  Early in 2009, with my youngest child leaving for college in the fall, I wanted to come up with a new, maybe seasonal , business venture. Being in close proximity to Silver Lake & Letchworth State Park, something fun like a good old fashioned ice cream parlor came to mind.
  Candy seemed like the perfect thing to go along with the ice cream!  A lot of trial & error later, our cases & shelves are bursting with a huge variety of truffles, barks, caramels, clusters and so much more!

Baked Goods

Cookies, brownies & cupcakes of all varieties are to be found any time you drop in. Our ice cream cakes in three sizes are ready to be personalized on the spot or call ahead if there is something special you would like.

Special Orders

Do you have someone who loves a certain candy & you don't know where to find it? Give us a call & we will do our very best to create it for you. Is there a gluten allergy in your family?  We are happy to make something that will be enjoyed by the whole family!